who 'dat be?

Herschel, BB19, Nick Chubb, David Pollack, Hines Ward, SBIV, Aaaaaron Murray, Hearst, EZ. HW34 the favorite, the rest in order (though Hearst maybe should be higher on the list)

(07-16-2024, 12:13 PM)Replying to Concourse E Herschel, BB19, Nick Chubb, David Pollack, Hines Ward, SBIV, Aaaaaron Murray, Hearst, EZ.  HW34 the favorite, the rest in order (though Hearst maybe should be higher on the list)

That is an excellent list!

(07-16-2024, 12:13 PM)Replying to Concourse E Herschel, BB19, Nick Chubb, David Pollack, Hines Ward, SBIV, Aaaaaron Murray, Hearst, EZ.  HW34 the favorite, the rest in order (though Hearst maybe should be higher on the list)

hard to argue with this list

(07-16-2024, 12:13 PM)Replying to Concourse E Herschel, BB19, Nick Chubb, David Pollack, Hines Ward, SBIV, Aaaaaron Murray, Hearst, EZ.  HW34 the favorite, the rest in order (though Hearst maybe should be higher on the list)

ONE PLAYER?

(07-16-2024, 11:52 AM)Replying to Branton who 'dat be?

Mudcat

(07-16-2024, 12:52 PM)Replying to GriffWoody

(07-16-2024, 12:13 PM)Replying to Concourse E Herschel, BB19, Nick Chubb, David Pollack, Hines Ward, SBIV, Aaaaaron Murray, Hearst, EZ.  HW34 the favorite, the rest in order (though Hearst maybe should be higher on the list)

hard to argue with this list

might should have included Gurley - I used to love the way he enjoyed the success of his teammates as much as his own.  And that Auburn kickoff for a TD would have probably been an all time top 5 moments in Sanford had it not been called back.

---

(07-16-2024, 01:19 PM)Replying to Branton

(07-16-2024, 12:13 PM)Replying to Concourse E Herschel, BB19, Nick Chubb, David Pollack, Hines Ward, SBIV, Aaaaaron Murray, Hearst, EZ.  HW34 the favorite, the rest in order (though Hearst maybe should be higher on the list)

ONE PLAYER?

I picked one, I just listed the runners up!

(07-16-2024, 01:55 PM)Replying to Concourse E

(07-16-2024, 12:52 PM)Replying to GriffWoody

(07-16-2024, 12:13 PM)Replying to Concourse E Herschel, BB19, Nick Chubb, David Pollack, Hines Ward, SBIV, Aaaaaron Murray, Hearst, EZ.  HW34 the favorite, the rest in order (though Hearst maybe should be higher on the list)

hard to argue with this list

might should have included Gurley - I used to love the way he enjoyed the success of his teammates as much as his own.  And that Auburn kickoff for a TD would have probably been an all time top 5 moments in Sanford had it not been called back.

---

---

(07-16-2024, 02:41 PM)Replying to Toasty B

(07-16-2024, 01:55 PM)Replying to Concourse E

(07-16-2024, 12:52 PM)Replying to GriffWoody

(07-16-2024, 12:13 PM)Replying to Concourse E Herschel, BB19, Nick Chubb, David Pollack, Hines Ward, SBIV, Aaaaaron Murray, Hearst, EZ.  HW34 the favorite, the rest in order (though Hearst maybe should be higher on the list)

hard to argue with this list

might should have included Gurley - I used to love the way he enjoyed the success of his teammates as much as his own.  And that Auburn kickoff for a TD would have probably been an all time top 5 moments in Sanford had it not been called back.

---

Fuckin Mudcat

Andy Johnson

There have been (and still are) lots of good ones. I have to say Herschel, though. Timing plays a part in that, as well as his vastly supreme level of talent, more so during his day when he played. Timing-wise, though... Herschel's senior year of high school was the same year as mine. I followed high school football fairly closely, and knew who he was even before the season began. I went to Senior Night at Six Flags during the spring of that school year, and actually stood in line about two people behind Herschel at the Scream Machine. When I left to go to Air Force basic training in late-September, Herschel was already making huge headlines. They had already played the Tennessee game, the Texas A&M game, and the Clemson game before I left. Right off the bat, my time in the Air Force was spent keeping up with the Dawgs, and especially Herschel.

I'm also biased toward Nick Chubb. He has a lot of comparable qualities of Herschel. I guess the one key difference was Herschel's legitimate world-class sprinter speed. That is an enormously rare commodity, though, especially for someone of his size.

Rob Dryden

The Mailman------------- Right ON!!!!!

Favorite player to watch. Herschel and it’s not close.

Favorite dawg. The mailman gave zero f@#$ and won 2 nattys in the process.

(07-16-2024, 12:13 PM)Replying to Concourse E Herschel, BB19, Nick Chubb, David Pollack, Hines Ward, SBIV, Aaaaaron Murray, Hearst, EZ.  HW34 the favorite, the rest in order (though Hearst maybe should be higher on the list)

Some others that might get consideration:

Champ Bailey
David Greene
Terry Hoage
Willy McClendon
Knowshon Moreno
McHonkey
Robert Edwards

Trippi