Posts: 3,541
Threads: 2,259
Joined: Dec 2023
07-07-2026, 09:38 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-07-2026, 09:39 PM by Top Row Dawg.)
Starts with Herschel #1
Honorable mentions:
Frank Sinkwich, QB (1940-43);
Charley Trippi, QB-RB (1941-44);
Bill Stanfill, DT (1966-68);
Eric Zeier, QB (1991-94);
Terrance Edwards (1999-2002);
David Greene, QB (2001-04);
Jake Fromm (2017-19).
Damn, I saw all seven of these guys in my lifetime.
Posts: 1,583
Threads: 1,134
Joined: Jan 2025
(07-07-2026, 09:38 PM)Replying to Top Row Dawg Starts with Herschel #1
Honorable mentions:
Frank Sinkwich, QB (1940-43);
Charley Trippi, QB-RB (1941-44);
Bill Stanfill, DT (1966-68);
Eric Zeier, QB (1991-94);
Terrance Edwards (1999-2002);
David Greene, QB (2001-04);
Jake Fromm (2017-19).
Damn, I saw all seven of these guys in my lifetime.
That list rings hollow without Stetson Bennett.
Posts: 1,639
Threads: 344
Joined: Dec 2023
(07-08-2026, 04:19 AM)Replying to Shootist Comitatus (07-07-2026, 09:38 PM)Replying to Top Row Dawg Starts with Herschel #1
Honorable mentions:
Frank Sinkwich, QB (1940-43);
Charley Trippi, QB-RB (1941-44);
Bill Stanfill, DT (1966-68);
Eric Zeier, QB (1991-94);
Terrance Edwards (1999-2002);
David Greene, QB (2001-04);
Jake Fromm (2017-19).
Damn, I saw all seven of these guys in my lifetime.
That list rings hollow without Stetson Bennett. 
Yeah, that list is not a good one. Bennett has to be 2, I’d rank Murray way ahead of Fromm and Green. Brock Bowers might be in the top 5. Even though he has the numbers, Edward’s wasn’t the best receiver we’ve had. I’d put Gurley, Chubb and Champ Bailey in the top 10.
Posts: 154
Threads: 21
Joined: Dec 2023
(07-07-2026, 09:38 PM)Replying to Top Row Dawg Starts with Herschel #1
Honorable mentions:
Frank Sinkwich, QB (1940-43);
Charley Trippi, QB-RB (1941-44);
Bill Stanfill, DT (1966-68);
Eric Zeier, QB (1991-94);
Terrance Edwards (1999-2002);
David Greene, QB (2001-04);
Jake Fromm (2017-19).
Damn, I saw all seven of these guys in my lifetime.
I wouldn't put A-aron in the top 50. Dude was responsible for our last losing season. He has stats because he started 4 years and we threw it all the time. Stet should in place of that rag arm
Posts: 4,237
Threads: 355
Joined: Dec 2023
I disagree with a lot of that list.